Summary

When it comes to baseball gloves, Rawlings stands tall as a renowned name, known for its enduring quality.

Each of these models differs mainly in their leather/shell composition and lining. While the leather and shell might be the same material, the distinction is likely for gloves with features like a mesh back. Notably, the R9 boasts "Durable All-Leather," yet the specific type of leather isn't specified.

Variations in linings exist across the board. Personally, I lean towards steerhide or kip liners for their lasting durability. However, sheepskin (with Pittards being a reputable brand) or cowhide offer softer textures and easier break-in. While "Padded Fingerback Liners" offer immediate comfort, they might not endure as well over time.

!IMPORTANT! Keep an eye out for R2G Heart of the Hides. They share the same leather quality but feature internals akin to an R9. This tradeoff prioritizes ease of use over long-term durability.

It's worth noting that only the Pro Preferred model mentions laces.

Overall, Rawlings remains a formidable choice. Their prevalence as the leading brand for MLB gloves, as highlighted in What Pros Wear's 2023 report, speaks volumes about their reputation and performance.